Food and Drink Brand Mysteries
Why products vanish from shelves, why chains drop favourites, and what is actually in the jar. The questions behind the headlines.
Some of Eat Pallet's most-read pieces were about products people loved and lost. The common thread is that brands rarely explain themselves, so the gap gets filled with rumour. Here is what is actually known.
What happened to Diet Dr Pepper?
It did not disappear, but it became hard to find twice, and it has been quietly displaced.
- The 2020 to 2021 shortages. Dr Pepper itself was in short supply from mid-2020 because demand for canned drinks at home jumped during lockdowns while aluminium can supply was constrained. Keurig Dr Pepper confirmed the shortage publicly in August 2020. Diet Dr Pepper was hit harder because production prioritised the core product.
- The sweetener shift. Diet Dr Pepper is sweetened with aspartame. The company's newer "Dr Pepper Zero Sugar", launched in 2021, uses an aspartame and acesulfame potassium blend designed to taste closer to the original, and it has taken much of the shelf space and marketing that Diet used to have.
- The flavour change rumour. Fans periodically report that Diet Dr Pepper "tastes different". Keurig Dr Pepper has not announced a reformulation. Changes in cans, water, storage temperature and simple ageing of the product on shelf all alter the taste of aspartame-sweetened drinks, which lose sweetness over time.
Diet Dr Pepper is still produced in the US as of 2024. In the UK, Dr Pepper Zero is the sugar-free version sold by Coca-Cola Europacific Partners, who hold the UK licence; "Diet Dr Pepper" as a UK product was replaced by Zero.
Why did Costco stop selling the combo pizza?
Costco's food courts in the US sold three pizzas for years: cheese, pepperoni and the "combo" (pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onions, mushrooms and olives). The combo was pulled in 2020 and has not come back nationally, despite petitions with tens of thousands of signatures.
- Costco's own explanation, given in responses to members, was that the combo was dropped to simplify the food-court menu during the pandemic, when food courts were reduced to takeaway only and staffing was tight. A pizza with six toppings takes longer to build and holds more ingredients in stock.
- Supply and consistency. The combo relied on fresh vegetables that varied by region and season, which is at odds with Costco's preference for a food-court menu that is identical in every warehouse.
- Margin. Costco's food court is famously run at near break-even (the $1.50 hot dog has not changed price since 1985). A pizza with the most toppings is the most expensive to make at the same selling price.
Some regional warehouses are reported to have reintroduced it for periods, and the combo has returned in some international markets, but at the time of writing there has been no US-wide return.
Is store-bought queso bad for you?
Jarred queso (the cheese dip sold next to the tortilla chips) is not dangerous, but it is a long way from cheese. The ingredient list on most mainstream brands runs to pasteurised processed cheese, whey, vegetable oils, modified starch, sodium phosphate, salt, and colourings. A typical 2-tablespoon serving carries around 40 to 60 calories, 3 to 4 grams of fat and 200 to 300 milligrams of sodium, and most people eat several servings in a sitting.
- The main concern is sodium. A few generous scoops can be a quarter of a day's recommended intake.
- It is an ultra-processed food by any definition: emulsifiers, modified starches and flavourings doing the work that cheese would do in a homemade version.
- Protein is low relative to real cheese, because the dip is mostly water, oil and starch.
A homemade queso takes ten minutes: grate a block of mild cheddar or Monterey Jack, toss it with a teaspoon of cornflour, and melt it slowly into a cup of warmed evaporated milk with chopped green chillies and a pinch of cumin. The cornflour and evaporated milk do the same emulsifying job as the sodium phosphate in the jar, and you control the salt. See our guide to ultra-processed foods for what to look for on labels.
Why brands go quiet
Three patterns explain almost every "what happened to" question about a food or drink product:
- Range rationalisation. Big food companies cut slow-selling variants, especially after 2020 when factory capacity was tight. A product does not need to be unpopular to be cut, only less popular than its neighbour on the line.
- Ingredient or packaging supply. A single shortage (cans, a sweetener, a spice) can take a product off shelves for months with no announcement.
- Quiet reformulation. Recipes change for cost, regulation (sugar taxes, colourant rules) or supplier reasons, and companies rarely say so. If a product "tastes different", it probably is.
Continue reading at HomeCooks
Evidence-based guides on food, cooking and nutrition.
- Balanced EatingThe fundamentals of eating well, without fads or fuss.
- Nutrition BasicsHow the macronutrients work and what a good plate looks like.
- Ultra-Processed FoodsWhat UPFs actually are and why the ingredient list matters.
- Meal Prep BasicsHow to cook once and eat well all week.
- What Counts as Fresh FoodA plain definition, and why it matters less than you think.
- Chef Food PhilosophyWhy food cooked with care simply tastes and feels better.
You can also revisit the original page on the Wayback Machine. Explore HomeCooks meals
