Cheap Ethnic Eatz · Archive · January 2013
How to Make Farmhouse Cheddar at Home
The first pressed cheese of the year, made without a press, without a mould, and with milk she mixed herself from powder and cream.
The December challenge, posted a little late in January, was a farmhouse cheddar or a Caerphilly: the group's first pressed cheese. Evelyne called the write-up a palpitating story in cheese-making, because she owned neither a cheese press nor a cheese mould, and because after the mozzarella saga she had decided to make her own milk.
Farmhouse cheddar is ready after a month and better at three. Christmas fell at her one-month mark, so she tried half and resealed the rest to wait. She was surprised by how much drier it was than shop cheddar, which is normal for this rustic style, and found the taste mild and lovely.
Making your own cheese-friendly milk
Scarred by four mozzarella attempts, she had become wary of shop milk. She could not prove the milk was the problem, but she found a workaround: mix non-chlorinated bottled water with a good-quality non-fat dried milk powder, then add cream. It has to be a decent brand of powder, such as Carnation, because cheaper ones may have been dried at too high a heat to work.
For 4 litres of milk: make up 4 litres of bottled water with dried milk powder according to the packet. Pour off 250 to 500ml to make room, then add 500ml of single cream (or 250ml of double cream). Mix well and leave it to rehydrate in the fridge overnight.
Improvising a mould and a press
After draining the curd she was supposed to put it in a mould and press it. Having neither, she cut the bottom off a two-litre milk carton and trimmed it to the right height. It was not practical and the curd kept trying to escape, but it did the job. For the press she stacked whatever weights she could find at each stage, guessing at about 25 pounds for the final pressing. She later found a bargain press on eBay and bought a proper mould.
Farmhouse Cheddar
Ingredients
- 4 litres (1 US gallon) milk
- 1/4 teaspoon calcium chloride, dissolved in 1/4 cup water
- 60g (2 oz) mesophilic culture cubes
- 1/4 teaspoon liquid rennet, dissolved in 1/4 cup water
- 1 tablespoon canning salt
Method
- Add the milk to a large pot and stir in the dissolved calcium chloride thoroughly. Heat the milk to 32C (90F), stirring.
- Add the mesophilic culture and stir until it has melted. Cover and leave to ripen for 45 minutes.
- Add the dissolved rennet, stirring for one minute in a gentle up-and-down motion. Cover and leave for 45 minutes to form curds.
- Test for a clean break by lifting a little curd with a knife. It should lift cleanly and the gap should fill with whey. Cut the curd into 1cm cubes and let it heal for five minutes.
- Heat the curds indirectly to 38C (100F), aiming for two degrees Fahrenheit every five minutes, by standing the pot in a sink of hot water at 38 to 43C and stirring often. It takes about 45 minutes; top the sink up with boiling water as needed and stir gently so the curds do not mat.
- Once at temperature, cover and rest for five minutes. Scoop the curds into a cheesecloth-lined colander, tie up the cloth and hang it for an hour.
- Take the curd down and break it apart with your fingers. Mix in the salt half a tablespoon at a time, waiting a minute between additions.
- Press in a cheesecloth-lined mould for 30 minutes at 4 to 5 pounds. Remove, unwrap, re-dress the cheese upside down and press at 10 to 12 pounds for an hour. Turn again and press at 20 to 25 pounds for 12 hours.
- Unwrap and air-dry for two to four days, turning twice a day, until a butter-coloured rind forms and the surface is dry to the touch.
- Seal in wax and age at 7 to 15C (45 to 60F) for up to three months.
Note: Farmhouse cheddar is drier and more crumbly than the cheddar you buy. With ageing the flavour becomes full and sharp.
The recipe
She combined two sources, On Just a Couple Acres and Chickens in the Road, into the version below.
Drying and waxing
She air-dried the cheddar for three days. A note for cat owners: dry it in a cupboard with the door cracked open. Then came the waxing. You need cheese wax, a metal bowl and a pastry brush. Sit the bowl in a slightly larger pan with a little water and melt the wax over a medium heat. Paint the cheese all over, making sure every patch is covered or mould will get in, then give it a second coat and let it set for a few minutes before storing.
More from Making Cheese at Home
The Cheesepalooza project. Part of the Cheap Ethnic Eatz archive kept by HomeCooks.
Part of the Cheap Ethnic Eatz archive (2009-2015), rebuilt so a good post still leads somewhere. Explore HomeCooks meals
